| Year | Horse |
|---|---|
| 1779 | Bridget |
| 1780 | Tetotum |
| 1781 | Faith |
| 1782 | Ceres |
| 1783 | Maid of the Oaks |
| 1784 | Stella |
| 1785 | Trifle |
| 1786 | Yellow Filly |
| 1787 | Annette |
| 1788 | Nightshade |
| 1789 | Tag |
| 1790 | Hippolyta |
| 1791 | Portia |
| 1792 | Volante |
| 1793 | Caelia |
| 1794 | Hermione |
| 1795 | Platina |
| 1796 | Parisot |
| 1797 | Nike |
| 1798 | Bellissima |
| 1799 | Bellina |
| 1800 | Ephemera |
| 1801 | Eleanor |
| 1802 | Scotia |
| 1803 | Theophania |
| 1804 | Pelisse |
| 1805 | Meteora |
| 1806 | Bronze |
| 1807 | Briseis |
| 1808 | Morel |
| 1809 | Maid of Orleans |
| 1810 | Oriana |
| 1811 | Sorcery |
| 1812 | Manuella |
| 1813 | Music |
| 1814 | Medora |
| 1815 | Minuet |
| 1816 | Landscape |
| 1817 | Neva |
| 1818 | Corinne |
| 1819 | Shoveler |
| 1820 | Caroline |
| 1821 | Augusta |
| 1822 | Pastille |
| 1823 | Zinc |
| 1824 | Cobweb |
| 1825 | Wings |
| 1826 | Lilias |
| 1827 | Gulnare |
| 1828 | Turquoise |
| 1829 | Green Mantle |
| 1830 | Variation |
| 1831 | Oxygen |
| 1832 | Galata |
| 1833 | Vespa |
| 1834 | Pussy |
| 1835 | Queen of Trumps |
| 1836 | Cyprian |
| 1837 | Miss Letty |
| 1838 | Industry |
| 1839 | Deception |
| 1840 | Crucifix |
| 1841 | Ghuznee |
| 1842 | Our Nell |
| 1843 | Poison |
| 1844 | The Princess |
| 1845 | Refraction |
| 1846 | Mendicant |
| 1847 | Miami |
| 1848 | Cymba |
| 1849 | Lady Evelyn |
| 1850 | Rhedycina |
| 1851 | Iris |
| 1852 | Songstress |
| 1853 | Catherine Hayes |
| 1854 | Mincemeat |
| 1855 | Marchioness |
| 1856 | Mincepie |
| 1857 | Blink Bonny |
| 1858 | Governess |
| 1859 | Summerside |
| 1860 | Butterfly |
| 1861 | Brown Duchess |
| 1862 | Feu de Joie |
| 1863 | Queen Bertha |
| 1864 | Fille de l'Air |
| 1865 | Regalia |
| 1866 | Tormentor |
| 1867 | Hippia |
| 1868 | Formosa |
| 1869 | Brigantine |
| 1870 | Gamos |
| 1871 | Hannah |
| 1872 | Reine |
| 1873 | Marie Stuart |
| 1874 | Apology |
| 1875 | Spinaway |
| 1876 (tie) | Camelia |
| 1876 (tie) | Enguerrande |
| 1877 | Placida |
| 1878 | Jannette |
| 1879 | Wheel of Fortune |
| 1880 | Jenny Howlet |
| 1881 | Thebais |
| 1882 | Geheimniss |
| 1883 | Bonny Jean |
| 1884 | Busybody |
| 1885 | Lonely |
| 1886 | Miss Jummy |
| 1887 | Reve d'Or |
| 1888 | Seabreeze |
| 1889 | L'Abbesse de Jouarre |
| 1890 | Memoir |
| 1891 | Mimi |
| 1892 | La Fleche |
| 1893 | Mrs. Butterwick |
| 1894 | Amiable |
| 1895 | La Sagesse |
| 1896 | Canterbury Pilgrim |
| 1897 | Limasol |
| 1898 | Airs and Graces |
| 1899 | Musa |
| 1900 | La Roche |
| 1901 | Cap and Bells |
| 1902 | Sceptre |
| 1903 | Our Lassie |
| 1904 | Pretty Polly |
| 1905 | Cherry Lass |
| 1906 | Keystone |
| 1907 | Glass Doll |
| 1908 | Signorinetta |
| 1909 | Perola |
| 1910 | Rosedrop |
| 1911 | Cherimoya |
| 1912 | Mirska |
| 1913 | Jest |
| 1914 | Princess Dorrie |
| 1915 | Snow Marten |
| 1916 | Fifinella |
| 1917 | Sunny Jane |
| 1918 | My Dear |
| 1919 | Bayuda |
| 1920 | Charlebelle |
| 1921 | Love in Idleness |
| 1922 | Pogrom |
| 1923 | Brownhylda |
| 1924 | Straitlace |
| 1925 | Saucy Sue |
| 1926 | Short Story |
| 1927 | Beam |
| 1928 | Toboggan |
| 1929 | Pennycomequick |
| 1930 | Rose of England |
| 1931 | Brulette |
| 1932 | Udaipur |
| 1933 | Chatelaine |
| 1934 | Light Brocade |
| 1935 | Quashed |
| 1936 | Lovely Rosa |
| 1937 | Exhibitionist |
| 1938 | Rockfel |
| 1939 | Galatea |
| 1940 | Godiva |
| 1941 | Commotion |
| 1942 | Sun Chariot |
| 1943 | Why Hurry |
| 1944 | Hycilla |
| 1945 | Sun Stream |
| 1946 | Steady Aim |
| 1947 | Imprudence |
| 1948 | Masaka |
| 1949 | Musidora |
| 1950 | Asmena (FR) |
| 1951 | Neasham Belle |
| 1952 | Frieze |
| 1953 | Ambiguity |
| 1954 | Sun Cap (FR) |
| 1955 | Meld |
| 1956 | Sicarelle (FR) |
| 1957 | Carrozza |
| 1958 | Bella Paola (FR) |
| 1959 | Petite Etoile |
| 1960 | Never Too Late |
| 1961 | Sweet Solera |
| 1962 | Monade (FR) |
| 1963 | Noblesse |
| 1964 | Homeward Bound |
| 1965 | Long Look |
| 1966 | Valoris (FR) |
| 1967 | Pia |
| 1968 | La Lagune (FR) |
| 1969 | Sleeping Partner |
| 1970 | Lupe |
| 1971 | Altesse Royale |
| 1972 | Ginevra |
| 1973 | Mysterious |
| 1974 | Polygamy |
| 1975 | Juliette Marny |
| 1976 | Pawneese |
| 1977 | Dunfermline |
| 1978 | Fair Salinia |
| 1979 | Scintillate |
| 1980 | Bireme |
| 1981 | Blue Wind |
| 1982 | Time Charter |
| 1983 | Sun Princess |
| 1984 | Circus Plume |
| 1985 | Oh So Sharp |
| 1986 | Midway Lady |
| 1987 | Unite |
| 1988 | Diminuendo |
| 1989 | Snow Bride [NOTE: Aliysa finished first but was disqualified due to the presence of an illegal substance in her urine, and Snow Bride moved up for the win.] |
| 1990 | Salsabil |
| 1991 | Jet Ski Lady |
| 1992 | User Friendly |
| 1993 | Intrepidity |
| 1994 | Balanchine |
| 1995 | Moonshell |
| 1996 | Lady Carla |
| 1997 | Reams of Verse |
| 1998 | Shahtoush |
| 1999 | Ramruma |
| 2000 | Love Divine |
| 2001 | Imagine |
| 2002 | Kazzia (GER) |
| 2003 | Casual Look |
| 2004 | Ouija Board |
| 2005 | Eswarah |
| 2006 | Alexandrova |
| 2007 | Light Shift |
| 2008 | Look Here |
| 2009 | Sariska |